• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Advertise
  • About Craft Brewing Business

Craft Brewing Business

Professional Insight, Unfiltered

  • News
  • Business & Marketing
  • Ingredients & Supplies
  • Packaging & Distribution
  • Equipment
  • Webinars & White Papers
  • COVID-19

Mass. beer distributors table bill to settle franchise law dispute with craft brewers

January 24, 2017Chris Crowell

Massachusetts State House government cbb crop

The Massachusetts’ beer distribution scene is constantly in controversy. Whether it is allegations of pay to play arrangements to get beers into bars or unfair distribution contract arrangements that won’t let brewers out, someone is usually upset. The latter is in regard to the franchise law in the state that makes it difficult (and expensive) for a craft brewer to get out of a distribution contract.

Craft brewers in the state have tabled bills to amend this for the past few years, to no avail, as the distributors believed the compromises “went to far.” One maverick brewery decided to launch its own craft-beer-only distribution company that is not going to hold breweries to those punitive contracts.

Well, maybe a compromise is nearing this year after the Beer Distributors of Massachusetts Inc. filed a bill that they think will provide breweries more choice and flexibility in these relationships. We are not sure there are enough concessions here to achieve that compromise, but we will await the Massachusetts Guild’s reaction on that. In the mean time, here are the details.

What is the current law?

Under current Massachusetts law, if an emerging brewery wants to dissolve its relationship with a distributor after six months, it needs a super good reason and proof to back it, and then it must provide a ton of compensation to the (potentially negligent) distributor. In some cases, the law could result in a brewer having to pay its distributor several years worth of revenue to leave.

In total, the legal hoops/costs plus the financial compensation often equals a cost impossible for a craft brewer to meet, which leaves them stuck in a damaging business relationship with no practical option for recourse, argues the craft brewer.

The craft brewers are seeking a solution that would more closely mirror the same type of private business contracts common in other industries.

What is the distributor point of view?

Everything comes down to what the distributors view as fair compensation for the business they will be losing out on.

As William A. Kelley, president of the Beer Distributors of Massachusetts, believes that not receiving this compensation is an “unreasonable position.” He puts it like this:

“It would allow breweries accounting for up to 20 percent of a distributor’s established business to walk out for no reason. That approach would devastate Massachusetts’s independent distributors and place over 2,000 jobs — including many good-paying union jobs — at serious risk.”

What does the new bill do?

The “Act to Promote Economic Development and Market Access for Emerging Businesses,” sponsored by Representative John J. Mahoney (D-Worcester), would allow privately owned and operated breweries that manufacture less than 30,000 barrels of beer (about 413,000 cases) per year to refuse to sell beer to any of their distributors at any time, for no reason at all.

This proposal was deemed an equitable solution for both parties, from the group’s perspective because those “emerging breweries” that meet that 30,000 bbl and under definition would receive more freedom but still allow for compensation to the distributor. From the bill (the bolding is ours for added emphasis):

(1) No termination of the right to distribute shall be effective until the wholesaler being terminated has received both written notice and full compensation as specified in this section.

(2) Upon any termination of the right to distribute pursuant to this section, the wholesaler shall sell and the Emerging Brewery or the wholesaler newly assigned to distribute the brands being terminated shall repurchase the wholesaler’s inventory and sales and marketing materials.

The Emerging Brewery shall cause to be paid to the affected wholesaler, as full compensation for termination of the right to distribute the brands of an Emerging Brewery, an amount not less than the laid-in cost of the inventory plus the laid-in cost of the sales and marketing material plus the fair market value of the distribution rights for the brands which are being terminated by the Emerging Brewery.

Vague terms like “fair market value” are annoying to be sure. We can already foresee all of the unagreeing that will happen when two sides try to define it, but here is how it is explained in the bill.

“The price that the wholesaler’s business that is related to the terminated brands of the Emerging Brewery would sell for in an arms length transaction between a willing buyer and a willing seller as of the date the notice was received by the wholesaler being terminated.”

If the Emerging Brewery and the affected wholesaler cannot agree on the compensation due to the affected wholesaler, either the affected wholesaler or the Emerging Brewery may request that the amount of compensation be determined by final binding arbitration.

boston-craft-beer-distributors
Bills are proposed, but Mass. distributors, brewers still don’t agree on franchise law solution
Distribution contract law
Distribution contracts: What to know before you sign
brewing lawsuit
Mass. Franchise Law UPDATE: Judge denies Atlantic’s injunction, Jack’s Abby heads to arbitration
Beer-hand-cheers-congrats-gold-yellow
Good news: Congress’ COVID-19 relief makes federal craft beer excise tax reforms permanent

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Primary Sidebar

Latest News

  • This resplendent Oregon hop farm has the ultimate beer garden (TopWire Hop Project) reopening April 30 (enjoy some images)
  • This Get Your Drink On app gifts beer money to a phone’s digital wallet, so please send me some
  • New Yuengling limited-edition desert camo Lager cans honor vets and allow drinkers to engage with a Snapchat Yuengling eagle
  • Arryved debuts OpenTab to change the on-premise POS game

Sign up for our newsletter

unsubscribe from list

Most Popular Today

Recent Features

  • Crosby Farm TopWire Hop Project 12This resplendent Oregon hop farm has the ultimate beer garden (TopWire Hop Project) reopening April 30 (enjoy some images)
    April 15, 2021
  • Get Your Drink On app people cheers drinksThis Get Your Drink On app gifts beer money to a phone’s digital wallet, so please send me some
    April 15, 2021
  • GEA-InsightPartner-ProduktbildInside the real-time process control of GEA’s InsightPartner software
    April 14, 2021
  • roughhouse brewing cave aged beersCave-aged beer finally excavated by Roughhouse and other beers to know this week
    April 13, 2021
  • Distribution update: 21st Amendment heads to Hawaii, Upland Brewing to Chicago, Ceria Brewing to Texas/Puerto Rico and lots more news
    April 13, 2021
  • CODO Can design backgroundExploring canning trends and the can shortage with CanSource
    April 12, 2021

Footer

  • Email Newsletter Sign Up
  • About Craft Brewing Business
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise on Craft Brewing Business
  • Media Kit Download
  • Privacy and Terms

© 2021 · CBB Media LLC

Continue ...

sponsored by